Evaluating Online Sources

The World Wide Web has a lot to offer, but not all sources are equally valuable or reliable. Anyone can put anything on the web without being censored or verified. It is difficult to sift through the information to evaluate it. Use this checklist as a guide to aid in evaluation.

  • Authority
    Who is the author? Have you heard of him before? Is he an acknowledged expert in this particular subject area?
    What organization is sponsoring the page? Is this an organization you've heard of before? Does it have a presence in the real world as well as online?
    Can you follow the links back to find out how the page is related to a larger authority? Does the domain of the page influence your evaluation of the site?

     
  • Accuracy
    Are the sources for any factual information clearly listed so they can be verified in another source?
    Is the information free of grammatical, spelling and typographical errors?

     
  • Objectivity
    What is the point of view? Does the information seem biased?
    Is there advertising on the page? Is it clearly separated from the information content?
    Does the web information contradict something you found somewhere else?
    Are opinion pages clearly labeled?

     
  • Coverage
    Does the page cover the information that you need? Is it too elementary or too technical?
    Is the information primary or secondary in nature? Does it matter?
    Does the page include links to other pages that back up the information?

     
  • Currency
    When was the document created? When was the page last updated? Does currency matter for your purpose?

"Evaluation of Websites." ISLMA. 3 Dec. 2008 <http://www.islma.org/resources.htm>.

 

Resources for Evaluating Web Sources

Critical Evaluation of a Website Checklist

Criteria for Evaluation of a Website:  The Ohio State University
Thinking Critically About World Wide Web Resources:  UCLA Library Evaluating Web Pages:  Duke University

 

 

Citing  and Writing Page

Library Home Page

CUSD 10